I’m glad Aubrey Hamilton talked me into reading Charles Finch’s first Charles Lenox mystery, A Beautiful Blue Death. It was a finalist for the 2007 Agatha Award for Best First Novel. I had read a recent one in the series, but I never started at the beginning. It’s a satisfying mystery, an easy read with dry humor. It’s slow-paced, with an unforgettable protagonist, and other multilayered characters. Best of all, it’s set in 1865 in London. Victorian England is my favorite time period for historical mysteries.

“Lenox, perhaps the premier amateur investigator of his era”, has the money to live in Mayfair, the most prestigious address in London, and lives next door to a widow, Lady Jane Grey, who was a close childhood friend. Lady Jane is the one who drags Lenox into his latest case when she says Prudence Smith, a former maid, has been found dead, and she suspects murder. At her request, Lenox goes to the home of George Barnard, a wealthy man who employed Prudence. The body is still in her room, and Lenox and a good friend, Dr Thomas McConnell, suspect the young woman was poisoned. Barnard insists she committed suicide, and Inspector Exeter from Scotland Yard immediately agrees with Barnard, and pushes Lenox out of the picture.

But Lenox feels for the young maid, and he can’t let down Lady Jane. He doesn’t really suspect any of the servants, but he finds an unusual group of guests staying at Barnard’s house. As Director of the Mint, Barnard has a great deal of clout, and he and Exeter use pressure to insist on suicide. Even though Lenox is attacked in an alley, his brother and friends help him quietly investigate. Even Exeter asks for help before there’s another murder in Barnard’s house, this time during a ball.

I have an enormous TBR pile, but Charles Lenox, Lady Jane, and Lenox’ butler, Graham, will bring me back to this series. There’s a great deal of period historical detail, including the background provided by the details of the daily life of a gentleman during the 1860s. It’s a pleasure to step into Charles Lenox’ world.

A Beautiful Blue Death by Charles Finch. St. Martin’s Minotaur, 2007. 324p.


FTC Full Disclosure – Library book