
If you can get through the first two brutal, dramatic chapters of Nora Roberts’ Birth of the Witch, you’ll appreciate the first in A Coven of Three trilogy. It’s a story of power, dark and light, lies and truth, and found and birth family. It’s the kind of vivid book that has become Roberts’ recent trilogies.
This is not a spoiler because the book jacket reveals the tragedy. Niamh McShane was an indentured servant on Piety Island in the Massachusetts Bay Colony in 1695. She was orphaned, just thirteen, working in the Downing household, when she was accused of witchcraft by respectable people on the island including the local doctor and minister. She was flung into jail along with two women who were weavers, Dorcas and Elspeth. Although they couldn’t save her, Dorcas and Elspeth, along with a teenage boy who was desperate to stop the hanging, joined their power together when Niamh was hanged. Niamh McShane was born a witch in the moment she died.
In 2013, when Neve McShane turned thirteen, her found family, her aunts Dorcas and Elspeth, told her she had come into her power, and she was a witch. They had been with her through numerous lifetimes, but in this lifetime, she had a power that dark forces craved. The First, the revered powerful witch, told Neva of her future, and a quest for sacred items that would assist Neva in fighting the forces of evil. She vowed to be a servant of the light, of The First. She may have been the innocent one when she was hanged, but she has been given power.
Neve isn’t the only one with power. Caden Quinn was born a witch to an Irish family with powers. He grew up knowing he was to serve the First, and protect the one she has chosen to do battle for her. But, Caden and Neve both have to learn their own magicks and power before their time will come to finally meet. They’ll both be tested before they face the evil in battle.
There are beautiful descriptions in this book, descriptions of Ireland and the tranquility there, that are set against the ugliness of Piety Island in 1695. But, those are just a couple of the places where Caden, Neve, Dorcas and Elspeth lives over the centuries. Now, it’s time to come home and face evil again. Those four characters are original, appealing characters in whatever lifetime they’re living.
Birth of the Witch has some of the qualities normally seen in the second book in one of Roberts’ trilogies. There’s a lot of waiting, a great deal of training needed before either Neve or Caden are ready to even meet each other. Usually, I notice a great deal of training time and character introduction in the second book. But, I can see why Roberts’ did this. The main characters are young, and have to grow into their powers, and find their way before they can battle for power and the light.
Nora Roberts’ website is https://noraroberts.com/
Birth of the Witch by Nora Roberts. St. Martin’s Press, 2026. 432p.
FTC Full Disclosure – I read a galley, supplied by the publisher through NetGalley, with no expectation of a positive review.


