I was so tempted to just copy the list I made for Kaye Wilkinson Barley’s Meanderings and Muses site when she asked a bunch of her female friends to give her a list of our favorite books of 2020, http://bit.ly/2Jvybk0. However, I went back one more time. And, I realized I haven’t really been fair to one whole sub-genre of books, one that I enjoy. So, more later.

First, I’m going to give you a heads-up about two books you might want to watch for in 2021. Josh Stallings’ Tricky is a Jan. 19 release. After arresting a murder suspect, a maverick cop tries to prove the man isn’t a killer. Oh, but you’ll have to read the book, or at least my January review. There’s so much meat in this book.

In March, you’ll want to pick up SJ Bennett’s The Windsor Knot. Just before her 90th birthday, Queen Elizabeth II turns sleuth when a guest is found dead in one of the bedrooms at Windsor Castle. The queen turns to her assistant private secretary to serve as her legs in this case. I loved this original mystery, and have high hopes for the series. Bennett plans to go backwards in the queen’s reign to reveal some of her other cases. And, she says one model for this series was Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin. Release date is March 9.

Now, let’s talk about the books of 2020, an excellent year for reading, if not an excellent year for anything else. There were some terrific books that were released in 2020. However, when the library shut down in mid-March, I was stunned. I couldn’t read anything for two weeks. Finally, historical romances pulled me out of that reading coma. None of those books were published this year, so they’re not on the favorites list. But, I have to give thanks for Julia Quinn’s Bridgertons series (yes, the one on Netflix that I am not watching because I’m a history snob), and Sarah MacLean’s Scandal & Scoundrel series. Who knows what I’d be talking about now if it wasn’t for those books?

What I did discover when I went back through my list of books is that cozy mysteries seldom appear on my final lists. Why? Although there were several that I raved about when I read them, when I narrow my choices for the final list of favorites, there are often books that are more memorable. So, instead of narrowing the list this year, I’m expanding it. This is not a top-ten list or a best of list. It’s my personal list of favorites, and there are several cozy mysteries that deserve to appear here. So, the current list is not the same one that appeared at Meanderings and Muses. It’s my current, as of today, list of favorite books that I read that were released in 2020. Alphabetical order by author because I’m a librarian.

Bree Baker’s Closely Harbored Secrets makes the list, not just because it’s fresh in my memory since I just finished it this weekend. This is the fifth in the series featuring Everly Swan, owner of a cafe and tea shop in Charm, North Carolina. Not one of these books has been a disappointment. If you’re looking for a strong cozy mystery series with likeable characters, you might want to try the Seaside Cafe mysteries, beginning with Live and Let Chai. This one, in which Everly becomes the target of a killer, although she doesn’t have what he’s looking for, might be my favorite in the series. The series features strong family history elements, a little woo-woo, and great characters.

Carousels of Paris is by my friend Kaye Wilkinson Barley, with photographs by Kaye and her husband, Don Barley. It’s a gorgeous book of photographs and some background history of the carousels that are dotted around Paris. It’s a beautiful gift book for anyone who loves carousels or unusual sites in Paris itself. Expect the unexpected animals, even extinct ones, on some of these stunning carousels. (And, I’m happy to say I contacted the American Library in Paris, and they corrected their wrong cataloging for this book – smile.)

What is is about the fifth book in a mystery series? The Solace of Bay Leaves by Leslie Budewitz is the fifth in her Spice Shop series, and it’s one of the best in the series. Maybe it’s because, by this time in the series, the amateur sleuth has more confidence. When Pepper Reece’s childhood friend, Maddie, is shot and gravely injured, it’s reminiscent of an unsolved murder that left another friend a widow. For me, the focus of this book was Pepper, an introspective, mature woman who struggles with her insecurities while still trying to improve her relationships and her knowledge of herself.

Harlan Coben’s The Boy from the Woods still stands out for me, although I read it in March. I read for character first, and Wilde, the man who grew up in the woods, and Hester Crimstein, a TV criminal attorney, are both memorable characters. When a teenage girl goes missing, Hester’s grandson lets her know the girl was bullied in school. She drags Wilde into the case, one that leads to a complicated mess involving a powerful family, and secrets. I’d like to see both of these characters again.

The cover of Emily Henry’s Beach Read doesn’t do it justice. January Andrews is a romance writer who has had writer’s block ever since her father’s death. Augustus Everett is a bestselling literary author who is her next-door neighbor at a beach house for the summer. He was her rival in college, and she always felt he looked down on her. Now, the two agree to swap writing styles for the summer. He’ll try to write a happily-ever-after story while she’ll try to write a literary novel. They’ll both finish a novel, and they’ll learn something about each other and the writing process. This is meatier than the cover makes it appear as it probes the lives of two writers with troubled backgrounds.

While Craig Johnson’s novella, Spirit of Steamboat, remains my favorite Longmire book, Next to Last Stand may come in second. I still laugh when I think of the final chase scene in this book. The book centers on a painting of “Custer’s Last Fight”, seen in every bar in America. The original was lost in a fire at Fort Bliss, Texas, in 1946. Maybe? When Charley Lee Stillwater dies at the Wyoming Home for Soldiers & Sailors, Sheriff Walt Longmire is called in to discover the connection between a piece of a painting and a shoebox containing a million dollars.

Jess Lourey’s novel, Unspeakable Things, was released in January 2020, before COVID, and so early in the year that many may have forgotten it. I can’t forget this coming-of-age story featuring a young girl, Cassie McDowell, a twelve-year-old unreliable narrator. It’s set in a small Minnesota town where young boys are abducted, and returned, changed. And, then one boy is abducted, and doesn’t come back. When you read the Author’s Note in Lourey’s novel, and learn that she was inspired by true incidents from her own childhood, the story becomes even more powerful. This story is so wrong, and so beautifully written. When Cassie says, “Kids are being taken,” a girl her age replies, “I’m not going to let them steal my childhood, though.” It’s a story of stolen childhoods, broken dreams, and loss.

I was torn between two books by Jenn McKinlay. Buried to the Brim is an excellent cozy mystery in her London Hat Shop series. I went with her romantic comedy, Paris is Always a Good Idea. It’s classic McKinlay with one part laughter and one part madcap physical comedy as workaholic Chelsea Martin sets out to revisit the three places where she was happiest, places where she fell in love with different men. Chelsea’s off to Ireland, Paris, and Italy. But, she can’t seem to escape from her arch-rival at work, Jason Knightley, the bane of her existence. Everyone else seems to love him and his humor. Everyone except Chelsea.

Sarah Morgenthaler’s debut novel, The Tourist Attraction, made my July list of Favorite Books of the Year, so far. It’s still on the list. In the fun romantic comedy set in Alaska, a diner owner, Graham Barnett, falls for a tourist despite his normal dislike and hands-off policy. In fact, he is so hands-off he named his diner The Tourist Trap and fights off tourists who try to approach the local moose, Ulysses. But, Zoey Caldwell, who saved all her money for her two week bucket list trip to Alaska, wins over Graham Barnett.

Although Richard Osman is a TV personality in England, The Thursday Murder Club is his debut novel. If you missed it, you should still pick it up. It was on a number of Best of lists this year, as well as Bestseller Lists here and abroad, and deservedly so. Osman introduces a savvy quartet of septuagenarians who are intrigued by cold cases and murder. They meet every Thursday to go over cold cases, but, when a real murder occurs in front of them, they prove equally adept at manipulating the police. It’s a humorous, sometimes laugh aloud story with intelligence and wit. At the same time, it’s bittersweet. The members of the group are all too aware of their own mortality, of the loss of memory of their loved ones, of the time when they themselves might suffer from dementia or illness. Death stares them in the face on a daily basis, so a murder investigation has nothing to scare them.

As much as I love Louise Penny’s Armand Gamache books, they don’t always make my favorites list. All the Devils Are Here may be my favorite in the series. It doesn’t hurt that it opens up in the gardens of the Rodin Museum in Paris, and I’ve been there. Gamache’s whole family is in Paris, awaiting the birth of a baby, when his godfather is struck by a hit-and-run driver, and left in critical condition. What starts as an investigation involving a car “accident” grows to involve the entire family, and a situation that could involve millions of people. It’s a story of family, love, and trust, and, as always in Penny’s books, dark and light, goodness and evil.

S.C. Perkins’ Lineage Most Lethal is the type of mystery that gets forgotten on these lists. However, the second of her Ancestry Detective Mysteries was even better than her solid debut. When I first reviewed this book, I raved about genealogist Lucy Lancaster’s confidence in herself. “I don’t apologize for loving learning and information. I’m smart, I’m good at my job, I work hard, and I’m proud of it.” Lucy is researching family for a hotel heiress when a dying man asks her to “Keep them safe”, whatever that means. However, her grandfather, who was in intelligence in World War II, understands the clue of a pen, and the link to a small group of spies. Perkins’ characters are great! But, I urge you not to read the flap of the book, and to start with the first in the series, if you can. It’s Murder Once Removed.

Jason Pinter’s Hide Away has made all of my lists this year because of the protagonist, Rachel Marin. I appreciate complex women, and they don’t come more complicated than Rachel Marin. She and her two children were once victims of a horrendous crime. Now, she tries to fly under the radar, living in a new community in Illinois. But, when the former mayor’s sudden death hits the headlines, Rachel steps up, convinced the woman did not kill herself. The local detectives won’t believe everything she tells them, so she turns vigilante to get justice for another woman.

Once again, Deanna Raybourn blends history and rumor, atmosphere and secrets into a remarkable novel. She’s a gifted storyteller,  who creates one of the eeriest moments in literature when Veronica is momentarily alone in an alley. However Raybourn’s true gift is in her creation of characters with their flaws and eccentricities and strengths. She can write of Scotland Yard, the royal family, Jack the Ripper, and combine all those elements into a compelling mystery. But, she can give us strong, independent characters such as Veronica Speedwell and Stoker. Raybourn brings Veronica Speedwell and Stoker back in an exciting mystery set at the time of the Whitechapel murders, Jack the Ripper. A Murderous Relation has so many connotations in this masterful story of family secrets and masquerades. And, the sexual tension left over from the last book, A Dangerous Collaboration, hangs over the relationship between Veronica and Stoker. No matter what their emotions, they’re always there to defend and protect each other.

It’s hard to know if Singular Sensation: The Triumph of Broadway by Michael Riedel would have made the list any other year. However, it’s the only nonfiction book on the list. When I read this book, it was also the only time I ever stayed up late to finish a nonfiction book. I seldom even do that with fiction. Singular Sensation takes us to Broadway in the 1990s in a gossipy, behind-the-scenes account of the people, particularly producers and playwrights, who created memorable shows. At a time when Broadway is dark, it reminds us what we’re missing with live theater.

While this isn’t the end of the list. Nora Roberts’ The Awakening tops my list for the year. The Awakening, the first in the Dragon Heart Legacy series, was perfect for me since I love Ireland so much. It’s fiction, fantasy, and a story of family, both those of blood and chosen families, families of the heart. It’s a book about choice, choice of family, choice of duty. When Breen Kelly travels to Ireland, she feels as if she’s come home. She doesn’t know she was born there, to her Irish father and American mother. And, she doesn’t know her connection to Talamh, a beautiful world of magick, a country where she’s in danger. But, Talamh itself needs Breen Kelly, and she’ll have choices to make. Nora Roberts brings her love of Ireland to this novel, the first in (probably) a trilogy of danger, love and magick.

Katharine Schellman’s The Body in the Garden is the third debut on the list. It came out in April, just in time to be forgotten due to COVID. With libraries and bookstores closed, and people still in shock, this appealing historical mystery was overlooked. Newly widowed Lily Adler teams up with a navy captain and an heiress from the West Indies to investigate a murder that Lily overheard. She was willing to leave the investigation to the authorities until she learned they had been paid to drop the case. Set in London 1815, this is an intriguing story of class, race, and society.

I always knew this mystery would make the final list of the year. I can’t speak highly enough about Sarah Stewart Taylor’s The Mountains WildI read this book twice, interviewed the author, talked with her for a virtual event, and raved about it to anyone who would listen. Taylor launches a new series featuring Maggie D’Arcy, a Long Island homicide cop who heads to Ireland twenty-three years after her cousin Erin disappeared there. It brings together a cold case, a police investigation, multiple time lines, and a love letter to Ireland.

Eighteen books, twenty if you count the two I told you to watch for in 2021. It’s twice the size of my usual favorites list. But, there were so many quality books this year, it was hard to narrow it down. And, just think of the books I missed! These are the ones I read, and loved, ones that were published in this never-to-be-forgotten year of 2020. Thank heavens there were wonderful books this year, or the entire year would have been a loss.

Here’s to the books of 2021!